Q & A of the Day - How best to test the heating to eliminate a fault?

BookmarkThis 07.03.2011
ECA
 

Our Voltimum Experts answer your questions on a daily basis in our Technical Expertise area. This Question of the Day, concerning a difficult to detect intermittent fault in a house, is answered by the ECA:

Intermittent faults can be difficult.
Intermittent faults can be difficult.
pixel
Question: We were recently called out to deal with an intermittent fault (shown by the RCD) covering the whole board. I have changed the board for an all-RCBO type, as no fault was found when circuits and appliances were tested, and PAT tested.

Now that the RCBOs have been fitted, we now know that the fault is on the downstairs ring. We carried out insulation tests on the ring main and found no fault. We unplugged everything so that the only item remaining was the central heating, which is off the ring main. The customer said that the boiler had been serviced, so there should have been nothing wrong with that - she thinks that it is our fault.

I know that service engineers don't carry out insulation tests. What is the best way to test the heating to eliminate the fault?

In the past, I have isolated the pump and the fault was found. Also, on another job, I found it was m/valve, but both of the above were easy to detect as the RCD would not re-set. However, with this fault, the problem is that as soon as the customer switches the RCBO back on, it is OK for a few days before it trips again!

Answer: One way is to isolate the heating system from the ring main and temporarily connect to another circuit to see if same thing happens. Alternatively, inspect, check and disconnect the electronic devices of the heating system and carry out insulation tests on the same.

To see many more Q & A in Voltimum UK's Experts Area, please click on the link:

www.voltimum.co.uk/consult.php?universe=consult.index.questions

 Back

 Related contacts
The Electrical Contractors' Association (ECA)
ECA Head Office, ESCA House,
34 Palace Court, London W2 4HY
Tel: 020 7313 4800
Fax: 020 7221 7344
Email: electricalcontractors@eca.co.uk
Web: www.eca.co.uk
blue arrow pointing right   ECA

 For latest electrical industry news, register for Voltimum's free newsletter.
Enter your email address here:
OK

Source: ECA & James Hunt

Related information

Related contacts

More News...

Q & A of the Day – Is this 1970s electrical installation still OK today?
Q & A of the Day - Please clarify how to connect this smoke alarm circuit?
Q & A of the Day - Should a wind turbine supply cable be earthed both ends?
Q & A of the Day – What testing is needed for this altered domestic kitchen circuit?
Q & A of the Day – Is this garage sub-distribution board earth CPC adequate?
Q & A of the Day – Are smoke detectors necessary for this toilet?
Q & A of the Day – Can I use this T&E cable as the sub-distribution board CPC?
Q & A of the Day – What connection for this circuit having an extra consumer unit?
Q & A of the Day – Can I use T&E cable for this sub-distribution board CPC?